Rounds Enabled

22, 23, 24, 25, 26, 27, 28, 29, 30, 31, 32, 33, 34, 35, 36

Details

• POV Information

Original Versions

• Original Build: CB1
• Author-supplied patches: CB1
• Author-supplied POVs: POV1
• Browse Source

Known Vulnerabilities

• CWE-126 - Buffer Over-read
CWEs are listed as indicated by the challenge author.

Deployed patches

• Round 24 : CodeJitsu - CB1 (disassembly)
• Round 24 : Shellphish - CB1 (disassembly)
• Round 24 : TECHx - CB1 (disassembly)
• Round 25 : CSDS - CB1 (disassembly)
• Round 25 : DeepRed - CB1 (disassembly)
• Round 25 : Shellphish - CB1 (disassembly)
• Round 27 : Disekt - CB1 (disassembly)
• Round 27 : TECHx - CB1 (disassembly)
• Round 36 : DeepRed - CB1 (disassembly)
• Round 36 : ForAllSecure - CB1 (disassembly)

Deployed IDS rules

• Round 25 - DeepRed

DARPA performer group

Kaprica Security (KPRCA)

Description

OTPSim provides a way to simulate an OTP (One Time Pad) code generation with limited sessions. When a client initiates the session with the handshake command, the client can generate up to 3 OTP codes of customizable length, unless the session is extended. The extension resets the counter back to 0, allowing the client to generate 3 more OTP codes. The service also provides a way to verify.

Feature List

- Handshake - Generate OTP token - Extend the session - Reset seed value and index - Verify token - Quit

Vulnerability

Vuln 1

• Extension feature receives random non-null bytes from the client and transmits the same content back (with a null byte prepended, indiciating success).
• The client controls the size field to let the service know how much of random bytes it should expect to read.
• However, the service fails to check if it actually has received said number of bytes -- it reads until a null byte or up to the max stack buffer size (8192).
• So, when a malicious client sets the size large, but sends less data than what it promised, memory beyond the random bytes (from the client) is read from the stack -- which may contain sensitive data.
• Since OTPSim uses secret page to generate token data, a malicious client can force the generation of an OTP token, which fills stack memory with data from secret page.
• Because the stack isn't initialized with the extension function, the memory can be leaked.

Generic class of vulnerability

Buffer Over-read

CWE classification

CWE-126: Buffer Over-read

Challenges

• Handshake involves some bit-arithmetic challenge/response procedure
• Need to realize that the stack memory isn't initialized, and may contain secret page data by forcing the service to generate OTP token
• Although there isn't a memory corruption (at least not intended), it is very real-world (Heartbleed) type of bug.

Difficulty

• Discovery: medium
• Proving: hard
• Patching: easy

Round	Source	Destination	Result	POV	Analysis	Video
23	CodeJitsu	CSDS	Successful POV	POV	Analysis	Watch
23	CodeJitsu	DeepRed	Successful POV	POV	Analysis	Watch
23	CodeJitsu	Disekt	Successful POV	POV	Analysis	Watch
23	CodeJitsu	ForAllSecure	Successful POV	POV	Analysis	Watch
23	CodeJitsu	Shellphish	Successful POV	POV	Analysis	Watch
23	CodeJitsu	TECHx	Successful POV	POV	Analysis	Watch
23	CSDS	CodeJitsu	Failed POV	POV		Watch
23	CSDS	DeepRed	Failed POV	POV		Watch
23	CSDS	Disekt	Failed POV	POV		Watch
23	CSDS	ForAllSecure	Failed POV	POV		Watch
23	CSDS	Shellphish	Failed POV	POV		Watch
23	CSDS	TECHx	Failed POV	POV		Watch
23	DeepRed	CodeJitsu	Failed POV	POV		Watch
23	DeepRed	CSDS	Failed POV	POV		Watch
23	DeepRed	Disekt	Failed POV	POV		Watch
23	DeepRed	ForAllSecure	Failed POV	POV		Watch
23	DeepRed	Shellphish	Failed POV	POV		Watch
23	DeepRed	TECHx	Failed POV	POV		Watch
23	ForAllSecure	CodeJitsu	Failed POV	POV		Watch
23	ForAllSecure	CSDS	Failed POV	POV		Watch
23	ForAllSecure	DeepRed	Failed POV	POV		Watch
23	ForAllSecure	Disekt	Failed POV	POV		Watch
23	ForAllSecure	Shellphish	Failed POV	POV		Watch
23	ForAllSecure	TECHx	Failed POV	POV		Watch
23	TECHx	CodeJitsu	Successful POV	POV	Analysis	Watch
23	TECHx	CSDS	Successful POV	POV	Analysis	Watch
23	TECHx	DeepRed	Successful POV	POV	Analysis	Watch
23	TECHx	Disekt	Successful POV	POV	Analysis	Watch
23	TECHx	ForAllSecure	Successful POV	POV	Analysis	Watch
23	TECHx	Shellphish	Successful POV	POV	Analysis	Watch
24	CodeJitsu	CSDS	Successful POV	POV	Analysis	Watch
24	CodeJitsu	DeepRed	Successful POV	POV	Analysis	Watch
24	CodeJitsu	Disekt	Successful POV	POV	Analysis	Watch
24	CodeJitsu	ForAllSecure	Successful POV	POV	Analysis	Watch
24	CodeJitsu	Shellphish	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
24	CodeJitsu	TECHx	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
24	CSDS	CodeJitsu	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
24	CSDS	DeepRed	Failed POV	POV		Watch
24	CSDS	Disekt	Failed POV	POV		Watch
24	CSDS	ForAllSecure	Failed POV	POV		Watch
24	CSDS	Shellphish	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
24	CSDS	TECHx	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
24	DeepRed	CodeJitsu	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
24	DeepRed	CSDS	Failed POV	POV		Watch
24	DeepRed	Disekt	Failed POV	POV		Watch
24	DeepRed	ForAllSecure	Failed POV	POV		Watch
24	DeepRed	Shellphish	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
24	DeepRed	TECHx	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
24	ForAllSecure	CodeJitsu	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
24	ForAllSecure	CSDS	Successful POV	POV	Analysis	Watch
24	ForAllSecure	DeepRed	Successful POV	POV	Analysis	Watch
24	ForAllSecure	Disekt	Successful POV	POV	Analysis	Watch
24	ForAllSecure	Shellphish	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
24	ForAllSecure	TECHx	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
24	TECHx	CodeJitsu	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
24	TECHx	CSDS	Successful POV	POV	Analysis	Watch
24	TECHx	DeepRed	Successful POV	POV	Analysis	Watch
24	TECHx	Disekt	Successful POV	POV	Analysis	Watch
24	TECHx	ForAllSecure	Successful POV	POV	Analysis	Watch
24	TECHx	Shellphish	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
25	CodeJitsu	CSDS	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
25	CodeJitsu	Disekt	Successful POV	POV	Analysis	Watch
25	CodeJitsu	ForAllSecure	Successful POV	POV	Analysis	Watch
25	CodeJitsu	Shellphish	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
25	CodeJitsu	TECHx	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
25	CSDS	CodeJitsu	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
25	CSDS	Disekt	Failed POV	POV		Watch
25	CSDS	ForAllSecure	Failed POV	POV		Watch
25	CSDS	Shellphish	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
25	CSDS	TECHx	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
25	DeepRed	CodeJitsu	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
25	DeepRed	CSDS	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
25	DeepRed	Disekt	Failed POV	POV		Watch
25	DeepRed	ForAllSecure	Failed POV	POV		Watch
25	DeepRed	Shellphish	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
25	DeepRed	TECHx	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
25	ForAllSecure	CodeJitsu	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
25	ForAllSecure	CSDS	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
25	ForAllSecure	Disekt	Successful POV	POV	Analysis	Watch
25	ForAllSecure	Shellphish	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
25	ForAllSecure	TECHx	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
25	TECHx	CodeJitsu	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
25	TECHx	CSDS	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
25	TECHx	Disekt	Successful POV	POV	Analysis	Watch
25	TECHx	ForAllSecure	Successful POV	POV	Analysis	Watch
25	TECHx	Shellphish	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
26	CodeJitsu	CSDS	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
26	CodeJitsu	DeepRed	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
26	CodeJitsu	Disekt	Successful POV	POV	Analysis	Watch
26	CodeJitsu	ForAllSecure	Successful POV	POV	Analysis	Watch
26	CodeJitsu	Shellphish	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
26	CodeJitsu	TECHx	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
26	CSDS	CodeJitsu	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
26	CSDS	DeepRed	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
26	CSDS	Disekt	Failed POV	POV		Watch
26	CSDS	ForAllSecure	Failed POV	POV		Watch
26	CSDS	Shellphish	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
26	CSDS	TECHx	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
26	DeepRed	CodeJitsu	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
26	DeepRed	CSDS	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
26	DeepRed	Disekt	Failed POV	POV		Watch
26	DeepRed	ForAllSecure	Failed POV	POV		Watch
26	DeepRed	Shellphish	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
26	DeepRed	TECHx	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
26	ForAllSecure	CodeJitsu	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
26	ForAllSecure	CSDS	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
26	ForAllSecure	DeepRed	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
26	ForAllSecure	Disekt	Successful POV	POV	Analysis	Watch
26	ForAllSecure	Shellphish	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
26	ForAllSecure	TECHx	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
26	TECHx	CodeJitsu	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
26	TECHx	DeepRed	Successful POV through defenses	POV	Analysis	Watch
26	TECHx	Disekt	Successful POV	POV	Analysis	Watch
26	TECHx	ForAllSecure	Successful POV	POV	Analysis	Watch
26	TECHx	Shellphish	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
27	CodeJitsu	CSDS	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
27	CodeJitsu	DeepRed	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
27	CodeJitsu	Disekt	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
27	CodeJitsu	ForAllSecure	Successful POV	POV	Analysis	Watch
27	CodeJitsu	Shellphish	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
27	CodeJitsu	TECHx	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
27	CSDS	CodeJitsu	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
27	CSDS	DeepRed	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
27	CSDS	Disekt	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
27	CSDS	ForAllSecure	Failed POV	POV		Watch
27	CSDS	Shellphish	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
27	CSDS	TECHx	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
27	DeepRed	CodeJitsu	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
27	DeepRed	CSDS	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
27	DeepRed	Disekt	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
27	DeepRed	ForAllSecure	Failed POV	POV		Watch
27	DeepRed	Shellphish	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
27	DeepRed	TECHx	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
27	ForAllSecure	CodeJitsu	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
27	ForAllSecure	CSDS	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
27	ForAllSecure	DeepRed	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
27	ForAllSecure	Disekt	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
27	ForAllSecure	Shellphish	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
27	ForAllSecure	TECHx	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
27	TECHx	CodeJitsu	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
27	TECHx	DeepRed	Successful POV through defenses	POV	Analysis	Watch
27	TECHx	Disekt	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
27	TECHx	ForAllSecure	Successful POV	POV	Analysis	Watch
27	TECHx	Shellphish	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
28	CodeJitsu	CSDS	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
28	CodeJitsu	DeepRed	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
28	CodeJitsu	Disekt	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
28	CodeJitsu	ForAllSecure	Successful POV	POV	Analysis	Watch
28	CodeJitsu	Shellphish	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
28	CodeJitsu	TECHx	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
28	CSDS	CodeJitsu	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
28	CSDS	DeepRed	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
28	CSDS	Disekt	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
28	CSDS	ForAllSecure	Failed POV	POV		Watch
28	CSDS	Shellphish	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
28	CSDS	TECHx	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
28	DeepRed	CodeJitsu	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
28	DeepRed	CSDS	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
28	DeepRed	Disekt	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
28	DeepRed	ForAllSecure	Failed POV	POV		Watch
28	DeepRed	Shellphish	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
28	DeepRed	TECHx	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
28	ForAllSecure	CodeJitsu	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
28	ForAllSecure	CSDS	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
28	ForAllSecure	DeepRed	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
28	ForAllSecure	Disekt	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
28	ForAllSecure	Shellphish	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
28	ForAllSecure	TECHx	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
28	Shellphish	ForAllSecure	Successful POV	POV	Analysis	Watch
28	Shellphish	TECHx	Successful POV through defenses	POV	Analysis	Watch
28	TECHx	CodeJitsu	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
28	TECHx	DeepRed	Successful POV through defenses	POV	Analysis	Watch
28	TECHx	ForAllSecure	Successful POV	POV	Analysis	Watch
28	TECHx	Shellphish	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
29	CodeJitsu	CSDS	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
29	CodeJitsu	DeepRed	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
29	CodeJitsu	Disekt	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
29	CodeJitsu	ForAllSecure	Successful POV	POV	Analysis	Watch
29	CodeJitsu	Shellphish	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
29	CodeJitsu	TECHx	Successful POV through defenses	POV	Analysis	Watch
29	CSDS	CodeJitsu	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
29	CSDS	DeepRed	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
29	CSDS	Disekt	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
29	CSDS	ForAllSecure	Failed POV	POV		Watch
29	CSDS	Shellphish	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
29	CSDS	TECHx	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
29	DeepRed	CodeJitsu	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
29	DeepRed	CSDS	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
29	DeepRed	Disekt	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
29	DeepRed	ForAllSecure	Failed POV	POV		Watch
29	DeepRed	Shellphish	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
29	DeepRed	TECHx	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
29	ForAllSecure	CodeJitsu	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
29	ForAllSecure	CSDS	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
29	ForAllSecure	DeepRed	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
29	ForAllSecure	Disekt	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
29	ForAllSecure	Shellphish	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
29	ForAllSecure	TECHx	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
29	Shellphish	CodeJitsu	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
29	Shellphish	DeepRed	Successful POV through defenses	POV	Analysis	Watch
29	Shellphish	ForAllSecure	Successful POV	POV	Analysis	Watch
29	Shellphish	TECHx	Successful POV through defenses	POV	Analysis	Watch
29	TECHx	CodeJitsu	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
29	TECHx	DeepRed	Successful POV through defenses	POV	Analysis	Watch
29	TECHx	ForAllSecure	Successful POV	POV	Analysis	Watch
29	TECHx	Shellphish	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
30	CodeJitsu	CSDS	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
30	CodeJitsu	DeepRed	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
30	CodeJitsu	Disekt	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
30	CodeJitsu	ForAllSecure	Successful POV	POV	Analysis	Watch
30	CodeJitsu	Shellphish	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
30	CodeJitsu	TECHx	Successful POV through defenses	POV	Analysis	Watch
30	CSDS	CodeJitsu	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
30	CSDS	DeepRed	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
30	CSDS	Disekt	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
30	CSDS	ForAllSecure	Failed POV	POV		Watch
30	CSDS	Shellphish	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
30	CSDS	TECHx	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
30	DeepRed	CodeJitsu	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
30	DeepRed	CSDS	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
30	DeepRed	Disekt	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
30	DeepRed	ForAllSecure	Failed POV	POV		Watch
30	DeepRed	Shellphish	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
30	DeepRed	TECHx	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
30	ForAllSecure	CodeJitsu	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
30	ForAllSecure	CSDS	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
30	ForAllSecure	DeepRed	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
30	ForAllSecure	Disekt	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
30	ForAllSecure	Shellphish	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
30	ForAllSecure	TECHx	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
30	Shellphish	CodeJitsu	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
30	Shellphish	DeepRed	Successful POV through defenses	POV	Analysis	Watch
30	Shellphish	ForAllSecure	Successful POV	POV	Analysis	Watch
30	Shellphish	TECHx	Successful POV through defenses	POV	Analysis	Watch
30	TECHx	CodeJitsu	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
30	TECHx	DeepRed	Successful POV through defenses	POV	Analysis	Watch
30	TECHx	ForAllSecure	Successful POV	POV	Analysis	Watch
30	TECHx	Shellphish	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
31	CodeJitsu	CSDS	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
31	CodeJitsu	DeepRed	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
31	CodeJitsu	Disekt	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
31	CodeJitsu	ForAllSecure	Successful POV	POV	Analysis	Watch
31	CodeJitsu	Shellphish	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
31	CodeJitsu	TECHx	Successful POV through defenses	POV	Analysis	Watch
31	CSDS	CodeJitsu	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
31	CSDS	DeepRed	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
31	CSDS	Disekt	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
31	CSDS	ForAllSecure	Failed POV	POV		Watch
31	CSDS	Shellphish	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
31	CSDS	TECHx	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
31	DeepRed	CodeJitsu	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
31	DeepRed	CSDS	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
31	DeepRed	Disekt	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
31	DeepRed	ForAllSecure	Failed POV	POV		Watch
31	DeepRed	Shellphish	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
31	DeepRed	TECHx	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
31	Disekt	CodeJitsu	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
31	Disekt	CSDS	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
31	Disekt	DeepRed	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
31	Disekt	ForAllSecure	Failed POV	POV		Watch
31	Disekt	Shellphish	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
31	Disekt	TECHx	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
31	ForAllSecure	CodeJitsu	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
31	ForAllSecure	CSDS	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
31	ForAllSecure	DeepRed	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
31	ForAllSecure	Disekt	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
31	ForAllSecure	Shellphish	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
31	ForAllSecure	TECHx	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
31	Shellphish	CodeJitsu	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
31	Shellphish	DeepRed	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
31	Shellphish	ForAllSecure	Successful POV	POV	Analysis	Watch
31	Shellphish	TECHx	Successful POV through defenses	POV	Analysis	Watch
31	TECHx	CodeJitsu	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
31	TECHx	DeepRed	Successful POV through defenses	POV	Analysis	Watch
31	TECHx	ForAllSecure	Successful POV	POV	Analysis	Watch
31	TECHx	Shellphish	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
32	CodeJitsu	CSDS	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
32	CodeJitsu	DeepRed	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
32	CodeJitsu	Disekt	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
32	CodeJitsu	ForAllSecure	Successful POV	POV	Analysis	Watch
32	CodeJitsu	Shellphish	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
32	CodeJitsu	TECHx	Successful POV through defenses	POV	Analysis	Watch
32	CSDS	CodeJitsu	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
32	CSDS	DeepRed	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
32	CSDS	Disekt	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
32	CSDS	ForAllSecure	Failed POV	POV		Watch
32	CSDS	Shellphish	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
32	CSDS	TECHx	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
32	DeepRed	CodeJitsu	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
32	DeepRed	CSDS	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
32	DeepRed	Disekt	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
32	DeepRed	ForAllSecure	Failed POV	POV		Watch
32	DeepRed	Shellphish	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
32	DeepRed	TECHx	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
32	Disekt	CodeJitsu	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
32	Disekt	CSDS	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
32	Disekt	DeepRed	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
32	Disekt	ForAllSecure	Successful POV	POV	Analysis	Watch
32	Disekt	Shellphish	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
32	Disekt	TECHx	Successful POV through defenses	POV	Analysis	Watch
32	ForAllSecure	CodeJitsu	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
32	ForAllSecure	CSDS	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
32	ForAllSecure	DeepRed	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
32	ForAllSecure	Shellphish	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
32	ForAllSecure	TECHx	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
32	Shellphish	CodeJitsu	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
32	Shellphish	DeepRed	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
32	Shellphish	ForAllSecure	Successful POV	POV	Analysis	Watch
32	Shellphish	TECHx	Successful POV through defenses	POV	Analysis	Watch
32	TECHx	CodeJitsu	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
32	TECHx	DeepRed	Successful POV through defenses	POV	Analysis	Watch
32	TECHx	ForAllSecure	Successful POV	POV	Analysis	Watch
32	TECHx	Shellphish	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
33	CodeJitsu	CSDS	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
33	CodeJitsu	DeepRed	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
33	CodeJitsu	Disekt	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
33	CodeJitsu	ForAllSecure	Successful POV	POV	Analysis	Watch
33	CodeJitsu	Shellphish	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
33	CodeJitsu	TECHx	Successful POV through defenses	POV	Analysis	Watch
33	CSDS	CodeJitsu	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
33	CSDS	DeepRed	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
33	CSDS	Disekt	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
33	CSDS	ForAllSecure	Failed POV	POV		Watch
33	CSDS	Shellphish	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
33	CSDS	TECHx	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
33	DeepRed	CodeJitsu	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
33	DeepRed	CSDS	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
33	DeepRed	Disekt	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
33	DeepRed	ForAllSecure	Failed POV	POV		Watch
33	DeepRed	Shellphish	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
33	DeepRed	TECHx	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
33	Disekt	CodeJitsu	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
33	Disekt	CSDS	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
33	Disekt	DeepRed	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
33	Disekt	ForAllSecure	Successful POV	POV	Analysis	Watch
33	Disekt	Shellphish	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
33	Disekt	TECHx	Successful POV through defenses	POV	Analysis	Watch
33	ForAllSecure	CodeJitsu	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
33	ForAllSecure	CSDS	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
33	ForAllSecure	DeepRed	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
33	ForAllSecure	Disekt	Successful POV through defenses	POV	Analysis	Watch
33	ForAllSecure	Shellphish	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
33	ForAllSecure	TECHx	Successful POV through defenses	POV	Analysis	Watch
33	Shellphish	CodeJitsu	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
33	Shellphish	DeepRed	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
33	Shellphish	ForAllSecure	Successful POV	POV	Analysis	Watch
33	Shellphish	TECHx	Successful POV through defenses	POV	Analysis	Watch
33	TECHx	CodeJitsu	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
33	TECHx	DeepRed	Successful POV through defenses	POV	Analysis	Watch
33	TECHx	ForAllSecure	Successful POV	POV	Analysis	Watch
33	TECHx	Shellphish	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
34	CodeJitsu	CSDS	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
34	CodeJitsu	DeepRed	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
34	CodeJitsu	Disekt	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
34	CodeJitsu	ForAllSecure	Successful POV	POV	Analysis	Watch
34	CodeJitsu	Shellphish	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
34	CodeJitsu	TECHx	Successful POV through defenses	POV	Analysis	Watch
34	CSDS	CodeJitsu	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
34	CSDS	DeepRed	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
34	CSDS	Disekt	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
34	CSDS	ForAllSecure	Failed POV	POV		Watch
34	CSDS	Shellphish	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
34	CSDS	TECHx	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
34	DeepRed	CodeJitsu	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
34	DeepRed	CSDS	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
34	DeepRed	Disekt	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
34	DeepRed	ForAllSecure	Failed POV	POV		Watch
34	DeepRed	Shellphish	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
34	DeepRed	TECHx	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
34	Disekt	CodeJitsu	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
34	Disekt	CSDS	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
34	Disekt	DeepRed	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
34	Disekt	ForAllSecure	Successful POV	POV	Analysis	Watch
34	Disekt	Shellphish	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
34	Disekt	TECHx	Successful POV through defenses	POV	Analysis	Watch
34	ForAllSecure	CodeJitsu	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
34	ForAllSecure	CSDS	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
34	ForAllSecure	DeepRed	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
34	ForAllSecure	Disekt	Successful POV through defenses	POV	Analysis	Watch
34	ForAllSecure	Shellphish	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
34	ForAllSecure	TECHx	Successful POV through defenses	POV	Analysis	Watch
34	Shellphish	CodeJitsu	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
34	Shellphish	DeepRed	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
34	Shellphish	ForAllSecure	Successful POV	POV	Analysis	Watch
34	Shellphish	TECHx	Successful POV through defenses	POV	Analysis	Watch
34	TECHx	CodeJitsu	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
34	TECHx	DeepRed	Successful POV through defenses	POV	Analysis	Watch
34	TECHx	ForAllSecure	Successful POV	POV	Analysis	Watch
34	TECHx	Shellphish	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
35	CodeJitsu	CSDS	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
35	CodeJitsu	DeepRed	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
35	CodeJitsu	Disekt	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
35	CodeJitsu	ForAllSecure	Successful POV	POV	Analysis	Watch
35	CodeJitsu	Shellphish	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
35	CodeJitsu	TECHx	Successful POV through defenses	POV	Analysis	Watch
35	CSDS	CodeJitsu	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
35	CSDS	DeepRed	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
35	CSDS	Disekt	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
35	CSDS	ForAllSecure	Failed POV	POV		Watch
35	CSDS	Shellphish	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
35	CSDS	TECHx	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
35	DeepRed	CodeJitsu	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
35	DeepRed	CSDS	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
35	DeepRed	Disekt	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
35	DeepRed	ForAllSecure	Failed POV	POV		Watch
35	DeepRed	Shellphish	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
35	DeepRed	TECHx	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
35	Disekt	CodeJitsu	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
35	Disekt	CSDS	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
35	Disekt	DeepRed	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
35	Disekt	ForAllSecure	Successful POV	POV	Analysis	Watch
35	Disekt	Shellphish	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
35	Disekt	TECHx	Successful POV through defenses	POV	Analysis	Watch
35	ForAllSecure	CodeJitsu	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
35	ForAllSecure	CSDS	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
35	ForAllSecure	DeepRed	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
35	ForAllSecure	Shellphish	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
35	ForAllSecure	TECHx	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
35	Shellphish	CodeJitsu	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
35	Shellphish	DeepRed	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
35	Shellphish	ForAllSecure	Successful POV	POV	Analysis	Watch
35	Shellphish	TECHx	Successful POV through defenses	POV	Analysis	Watch
35	TECHx	CodeJitsu	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
35	TECHx	DeepRed	Successful POV through defenses	POV	Analysis	Watch
35	TECHx	ForAllSecure	Successful POV	POV	Analysis	Watch
35	TECHx	Shellphish	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
36	CodeJitsu	CSDS	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
36	CodeJitsu	DeepRed	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
36	CodeJitsu	Disekt	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
36	CodeJitsu	ForAllSecure	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
36	CodeJitsu	Shellphish	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
36	CodeJitsu	TECHx	Successful POV through defenses	POV	Analysis	Watch
36	CSDS	CodeJitsu	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
36	CSDS	DeepRed	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
36	CSDS	Disekt	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
36	CSDS	ForAllSecure	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
36	CSDS	Shellphish	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
36	CSDS	TECHx	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
36	DeepRed	CodeJitsu	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
36	DeepRed	CSDS	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
36	DeepRed	Disekt	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
36	DeepRed	ForAllSecure	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
36	DeepRed	Shellphish	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
36	DeepRed	TECHx	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
36	Disekt	CodeJitsu	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
36	Disekt	CSDS	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
36	Disekt	DeepRed	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
36	Disekt	ForAllSecure	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
36	Disekt	Shellphish	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
36	Disekt	TECHx	Successful POV through defenses	POV	Analysis	Watch
36	ForAllSecure	CodeJitsu	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
36	ForAllSecure	CSDS	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
36	ForAllSecure	DeepRed	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
36	ForAllSecure	Disekt	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
36	ForAllSecure	Shellphish	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
36	ForAllSecure	TECHx	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
36	Shellphish	CodeJitsu	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
36	Shellphish	DeepRed	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
36	Shellphish	ForAllSecure	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
36	Shellphish	TECHx	Successful POV through defenses	POV	Analysis	Watch
36	TECHx	CodeJitsu	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
36	TECHx	DeepRed	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
36	TECHx	ForAllSecure	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
36	TECHx	Shellphish	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch