Rounds Enabled

20, 21, 22, 23, 24, 25, 26, 27, 28, 29, 30, 31, 32, 33, 34

Details

• POV Information

Original Versions

• Original Build: CB1
• Author-supplied patches: CB1
• Author-supplied POVs: POV1
• Browse Source

Known Vulnerabilities

• CWE-123 - Write-what-where Condition
• CWE-125 - Out-of-bounds Read
• CWE-465 - Pointer Issues
CWEs are listed as indicated by the challenge author.

Deployed patches

• Round 22 : CodeJitsu - CB1 (disassembly)
• Round 22 : Disekt - CB1 (disassembly)
• Round 22 : Shellphish - CB1 (disassembly)
• Round 23 : Shellphish - CB1 (disassembly)
• Round 25 : CodeJitsu - CB1 (disassembly)
• Round 26 : CSDS - CB1 (disassembly)
• Round 26 : DeepRed - CB1 (disassembly)
• Round 26 : Shellphish - CB1 (disassembly)
• Round 26 : TECHx - CB1 (disassembly)
• Round 28 : CodeJitsu - CB1 (disassembly)
• Round 29 : DeepRed - CB1 (disassembly)
• Round 31 : CodeJitsu - CB1 (disassembly)

Deployed IDS rules

• Round 26 - DeepRed
• Round 29 - DeepRed

DARPA performer group

Kaprica Security (KPRCA)

Description

A constant-time VM interpreter and validator written in C for fast data filtering. The user provides a filter program and a set of data, which is processed and the results returned.

Feature List

Separate validation and execution stages increases the performance of the interpreter as the amount of data increases. There is a one-time cost to make sure the program is correct, and then the interpreter can make assumptions that increase performance.

Support for many instructions: 13 arthimetic instructions, 4 conditional jumps, byte/half-word/word loads and stores, and read/write system calls. Loops are forbidden to guarantee that the execution is time-bound. During execution, the filter has access to a 1KB stack and the input data. Loads and stores are bounds-checked to prevent undefined behavior.

Vulnerability

Vuln 1

The VM interpreter keeps track of the value stored in each VM register and what memory space the VM register references. Normally, a VM register that holds a number will have a NULL memory space pointer. The interpreter takes advantage of this and ORs the memory space pointers together when performing an ADD or SUB instruction. This works because the validator enforces that the operands are either NUMBER-NUMBER, POINTER-NUMBER, or NUMBER-POINTER. So, the result of the OR is either NULL or a valid memory space pointer.

The interpreter fails to set the memory space pointer to NULL in some cases, which causes the aforementioned assumptions to break. This allows an attacker to construct a payload that results in the two memory space pointers being OR'd together, resulting in a memory space pointer that references attacker supplied memory, namely the VM registers. The attacker can set the length of this fake memory space structure to a large value and use a load instruction to read from any memory address or a store instruction to write to any address.

Generic class of vulnerability

Logic error

CWE classification

CWE-123: Write-what-where Condition CWE-125: Out-of-bounds Read CWE-465: Pointer Issues

Challenges

• The bug is in a virtual machine interpreter, which makes symbolic execution difficult
• The bug is dependent on the arrangement of heap allocations
• Patching is difficult because the bug is specific to this program and the memory access is inside of a loop that will affect performance if it is naively instrumented

Difficulty

• Discovery: hard
• Proving: medium
• Patching: hard

Round	Source	Destination	Result	POV	Analysis	Video
21	CSDS	CodeJitsu	Failed POV	POV		Watch
21	CSDS	DeepRed	Failed POV	POV		Watch
21	CSDS	Disekt	Failed POV	POV		Watch
21	CSDS	ForAllSecure	Failed POV	POV		Watch
21	CSDS	Shellphish	Failed POV	POV		Watch
21	CSDS	TECHx	Failed POV	POV		Watch
21	DeepRed	CodeJitsu	Failed POV	POV		Watch
21	DeepRed	CSDS	Failed POV	POV		Watch
21	DeepRed	Disekt	Failed POV	POV		Watch
21	DeepRed	ForAllSecure	Failed POV	POV		Watch
21	DeepRed	Shellphish	Failed POV	POV		Watch
21	DeepRed	TECHx	Failed POV	POV		Watch
21	ForAllSecure	CodeJitsu	Failed POV	POV		Watch
21	ForAllSecure	CSDS	Failed POV	POV		Watch
21	ForAllSecure	DeepRed	Failed POV	POV		Watch
21	ForAllSecure	Disekt	Failed POV	POV		Watch
21	ForAllSecure	Shellphish	Failed POV	POV		Watch
21	ForAllSecure	TECHx	Failed POV	POV		Watch
22	CodeJitsu	Disekt	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
22	CodeJitsu	Shellphish	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
22	CSDS	CodeJitsu	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
22	CSDS	DeepRed	Failed POV	POV		Watch
22	CSDS	Disekt	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
22	CSDS	ForAllSecure	Failed POV	POV		Watch
22	CSDS	Shellphish	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
22	CSDS	TECHx	Failed POV	POV		Watch
22	DeepRed	CodeJitsu	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
22	DeepRed	CSDS	Failed POV	POV		Watch
22	DeepRed	Disekt	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
22	DeepRed	ForAllSecure	Failed POV	POV		Watch
22	DeepRed	Shellphish	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
22	DeepRed	TECHx	Failed POV	POV		Watch
22	ForAllSecure	CodeJitsu	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
22	ForAllSecure	CSDS	Failed POV	POV		Watch
22	ForAllSecure	DeepRed	Failed POV	POV		Watch
22	ForAllSecure	Disekt	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
22	ForAllSecure	Shellphish	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
22	ForAllSecure	TECHx	Failed POV	POV		Watch
23	CodeJitsu	Shellphish	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
23	CSDS	CodeJitsu	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
23	CSDS	DeepRed	Failed POV	POV		Watch
23	CSDS	Disekt	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
23	CSDS	ForAllSecure	Failed POV	POV		Watch
23	CSDS	Shellphish	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
23	CSDS	TECHx	Failed POV	POV		Watch
23	DeepRed	CodeJitsu	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
23	DeepRed	CSDS	Failed POV	POV		Watch
23	DeepRed	Disekt	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
23	DeepRed	ForAllSecure	Failed POV	POV		Watch
23	DeepRed	Shellphish	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
23	DeepRed	TECHx	Failed POV	POV		Watch
23	ForAllSecure	CodeJitsu	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
23	ForAllSecure	CSDS	Failed POV	POV		Watch
23	ForAllSecure	DeepRed	Failed POV	POV		Watch
23	ForAllSecure	Disekt	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
23	ForAllSecure	Shellphish	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
23	ForAllSecure	TECHx	Failed POV	POV		Watch
24	CSDS	CodeJitsu	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
24	CSDS	DeepRed	Failed POV	POV		Watch
24	CSDS	Disekt	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
24	CSDS	ForAllSecure	Failed POV	POV		Watch
24	CSDS	Shellphish	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
24	CSDS	TECHx	Failed POV	POV		Watch
24	DeepRed	CodeJitsu	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
24	DeepRed	CSDS	Failed POV	POV		Watch
24	DeepRed	Disekt	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
24	DeepRed	ForAllSecure	Failed POV	POV		Watch
24	DeepRed	Shellphish	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
24	DeepRed	TECHx	Failed POV	POV		Watch
24	Disekt	CodeJitsu	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
24	Disekt	CSDS	Failed POV	POV		Watch
24	Disekt	DeepRed	Failed POV	POV		Watch
24	Disekt	ForAllSecure	Failed POV	POV		Watch
24	Disekt	Shellphish	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
24	Disekt	TECHx	Failed POV	POV		Watch
24	ForAllSecure	CodeJitsu	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
24	ForAllSecure	CSDS	Failed POV	POV		Watch
24	ForAllSecure	DeepRed	Failed POV	POV		Watch
24	ForAllSecure	Disekt	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
24	ForAllSecure	Shellphish	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
24	ForAllSecure	TECHx	Failed POV	POV		Watch
25	CSDS	CodeJitsu	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
25	CSDS	DeepRed	Failed POV	POV		Watch
25	CSDS	Disekt	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
25	CSDS	ForAllSecure	Failed POV	POV		Watch
25	CSDS	Shellphish	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
25	CSDS	TECHx	Failed POV	POV		Watch
25	DeepRed	CodeJitsu	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
25	DeepRed	CSDS	Failed POV	POV		Watch
25	DeepRed	Disekt	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
25	DeepRed	ForAllSecure	Failed POV	POV		Watch
25	DeepRed	Shellphish	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
25	DeepRed	TECHx	Failed POV	POV		Watch
25	Disekt	CodeJitsu	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
25	Disekt	CSDS	Failed POV	POV		Watch
25	Disekt	DeepRed	Failed POV	POV		Watch
25	Disekt	ForAllSecure	Failed POV	POV		Watch
25	Disekt	Shellphish	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
25	Disekt	TECHx	Failed POV	POV		Watch
25	ForAllSecure	CodeJitsu	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
25	ForAllSecure	CSDS	Failed POV	POV		Watch
25	ForAllSecure	DeepRed	Failed POV	POV		Watch
25	ForAllSecure	Disekt	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
25	ForAllSecure	Shellphish	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
25	ForAllSecure	TECHx	Failed POV	POV		Watch
26	CodeJitsu	CSDS	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
26	CodeJitsu	Shellphish	Failed POV	POV		Watch
26	CodeJitsu	TECHx	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
26	CSDS	CodeJitsu	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
26	CSDS	Disekt	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
26	CSDS	ForAllSecure	Failed POV	POV		Watch
26	CSDS	Shellphish	Failed POV	POV		Watch
26	CSDS	TECHx	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
26	DeepRed	CodeJitsu	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
26	DeepRed	CSDS	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
26	DeepRed	Disekt	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
26	DeepRed	ForAllSecure	Failed POV	POV		Watch
26	DeepRed	Shellphish	Failed POV	POV		Watch
26	DeepRed	TECHx	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
26	Disekt	CodeJitsu	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
26	Disekt	CSDS	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
26	Disekt	ForAllSecure	Failed POV	POV		Watch
26	Disekt	Shellphish	Failed POV	POV		Watch
26	Disekt	TECHx	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
26	ForAllSecure	CodeJitsu	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
26	ForAllSecure	CSDS	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
26	ForAllSecure	Disekt	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
26	ForAllSecure	Shellphish	Failed POV	POV		Watch
26	ForAllSecure	TECHx	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
27	CSDS	CodeJitsu	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
27	CSDS	DeepRed	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
27	CSDS	Disekt	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
27	CSDS	ForAllSecure	Failed POV	POV		Watch
27	CSDS	Shellphish	Failed POV	POV		Watch
27	CSDS	TECHx	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
27	DeepRed	CodeJitsu	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
27	DeepRed	CSDS	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
27	DeepRed	Disekt	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
27	DeepRed	ForAllSecure	Failed POV	POV		Watch
27	DeepRed	Shellphish	Failed POV	POV		Watch
27	DeepRed	TECHx	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
27	Disekt	CodeJitsu	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
27	Disekt	CSDS	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
27	Disekt	DeepRed	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
27	Disekt	ForAllSecure	Failed POV	POV		Watch
27	Disekt	Shellphish	Failed POV	POV		Watch
27	Disekt	TECHx	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
27	ForAllSecure	CodeJitsu	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
27	ForAllSecure	CSDS	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
27	ForAllSecure	DeepRed	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
27	ForAllSecure	Disekt	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
27	ForAllSecure	Shellphish	Failed POV	POV		Watch
27	ForAllSecure	TECHx	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
28	CSDS	CodeJitsu	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
28	CSDS	DeepRed	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
28	CSDS	Disekt	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
28	CSDS	ForAllSecure	Failed POV	POV		Watch
28	CSDS	Shellphish	Failed POV	POV		Watch
28	CSDS	TECHx	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
28	DeepRed	CodeJitsu	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
28	DeepRed	CSDS	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
28	DeepRed	Disekt	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
28	DeepRed	ForAllSecure	Failed POV	POV		Watch
28	DeepRed	Shellphish	Failed POV	POV		Watch
28	DeepRed	TECHx	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
28	Disekt	CodeJitsu	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
28	Disekt	CSDS	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
28	Disekt	DeepRed	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
28	Disekt	ForAllSecure	Failed POV	POV		Watch
28	Disekt	Shellphish	Failed POV	POV		Watch
28	Disekt	TECHx	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
28	ForAllSecure	CodeJitsu	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
28	ForAllSecure	CSDS	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
28	ForAllSecure	DeepRed	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
28	ForAllSecure	Disekt	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
28	ForAllSecure	Shellphish	Failed POV	POV		Watch
28	ForAllSecure	TECHx	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
29	CSDS	CodeJitsu	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
29	CSDS	Disekt	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
29	CSDS	ForAllSecure	Failed POV	POV		Watch
29	CSDS	Shellphish	Failed POV	POV		Watch
29	CSDS	TECHx	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
29	DeepRed	CodeJitsu	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
29	DeepRed	CSDS	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
29	DeepRed	Disekt	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
29	DeepRed	ForAllSecure	Failed POV	POV		Watch
29	DeepRed	Shellphish	Failed POV	POV		Watch
29	DeepRed	TECHx	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
29	Disekt	CodeJitsu	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
29	Disekt	CSDS	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
29	Disekt	ForAllSecure	Failed POV	POV		Watch
29	Disekt	Shellphish	Failed POV	POV		Watch
29	Disekt	TECHx	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
29	ForAllSecure	CodeJitsu	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
29	ForAllSecure	CSDS	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
29	ForAllSecure	Disekt	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
29	ForAllSecure	Shellphish	Failed POV	POV		Watch
29	ForAllSecure	TECHx	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
30	CSDS	CodeJitsu	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
30	CSDS	DeepRed	Failed POV	POV		Watch
30	CSDS	Disekt	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
30	CSDS	ForAllSecure	Failed POV	POV		Watch
30	CSDS	Shellphish	Failed POV	POV		Watch
30	CSDS	TECHx	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
30	DeepRed	CodeJitsu	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
30	DeepRed	CSDS	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
30	DeepRed	Disekt	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
30	DeepRed	ForAllSecure	Failed POV	POV		Watch
30	DeepRed	Shellphish	Failed POV	POV		Watch
30	DeepRed	TECHx	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
30	Disekt	CodeJitsu	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
30	Disekt	CSDS	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
30	Disekt	DeepRed	Failed POV	POV		Watch
30	Disekt	ForAllSecure	Failed POV	POV		Watch
30	Disekt	Shellphish	Failed POV	POV		Watch
30	Disekt	TECHx	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
30	ForAllSecure	CodeJitsu	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
30	ForAllSecure	CSDS	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
30	ForAllSecure	DeepRed	Failed POV	POV		Watch
30	ForAllSecure	Disekt	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
30	ForAllSecure	Shellphish	Failed POV	POV		Watch
30	ForAllSecure	TECHx	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
31	CSDS	CodeJitsu	Failed POV	POV		Watch
31	CSDS	DeepRed	Failed POV	POV		Watch
31	CSDS	Disekt	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
31	CSDS	ForAllSecure	Failed POV	POV		Watch
31	CSDS	Shellphish	Failed POV	POV		Watch
31	CSDS	TECHx	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
31	DeepRed	CodeJitsu	Failed POV	POV		Watch
31	DeepRed	CSDS	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
31	DeepRed	Disekt	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
31	DeepRed	ForAllSecure	Failed POV	POV		Watch
31	DeepRed	Shellphish	Failed POV	POV		Watch
31	DeepRed	TECHx	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
31	Disekt	CodeJitsu	Failed POV	POV		Watch
31	Disekt	CSDS	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
31	Disekt	DeepRed	Failed POV	POV		Watch
31	Disekt	ForAllSecure	Failed POV	POV		Watch
31	Disekt	Shellphish	Failed POV	POV		Watch
31	Disekt	TECHx	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
31	ForAllSecure	CodeJitsu	Failed POV	POV		Watch
31	ForAllSecure	CSDS	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
31	ForAllSecure	DeepRed	Failed POV	POV		Watch
31	ForAllSecure	Disekt	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
31	ForAllSecure	Shellphish	Failed POV	POV		Watch
31	ForAllSecure	TECHx	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
32	CSDS	CodeJitsu	Failed POV	POV		Watch
32	CSDS	DeepRed	Failed POV	POV		Watch
32	CSDS	Disekt	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
32	CSDS	ForAllSecure	Failed POV	POV		Watch
32	CSDS	Shellphish	Failed POV	POV		Watch
32	CSDS	TECHx	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
32	DeepRed	CodeJitsu	Failed POV	POV		Watch
32	DeepRed	CSDS	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
32	DeepRed	Disekt	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
32	DeepRed	ForAllSecure	Failed POV	POV		Watch
32	DeepRed	Shellphish	Failed POV	POV		Watch
32	DeepRed	TECHx	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
32	Disekt	CodeJitsu	Failed POV	POV		Watch
32	Disekt	CSDS	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
32	Disekt	DeepRed	Failed POV	POV		Watch
32	Disekt	ForAllSecure	Failed POV	POV		Watch
32	Disekt	Shellphish	Failed POV	POV		Watch
32	Disekt	TECHx	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
32	ForAllSecure	CodeJitsu	Failed POV	POV		Watch
32	ForAllSecure	CSDS	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
32	ForAllSecure	DeepRed	Failed POV	POV		Watch
32	ForAllSecure	Disekt	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
32	ForAllSecure	Shellphish	Failed POV	POV		Watch
32	ForAllSecure	TECHx	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
33	CSDS	CodeJitsu	Failed POV	POV		Watch
33	CSDS	DeepRed	Failed POV	POV		Watch
33	CSDS	Disekt	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
33	CSDS	ForAllSecure	Failed POV	POV		Watch
33	CSDS	Shellphish	Failed POV	POV		Watch
33	CSDS	TECHx	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
33	DeepRed	CodeJitsu	Failed POV	POV		Watch
33	DeepRed	CSDS	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
33	DeepRed	Disekt	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
33	DeepRed	ForAllSecure	Failed POV	POV		Watch
33	DeepRed	Shellphish	Failed POV	POV		Watch
33	DeepRed	TECHx	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
33	Disekt	CodeJitsu	Failed POV	POV		Watch
33	Disekt	CSDS	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
33	Disekt	DeepRed	Failed POV	POV		Watch
33	Disekt	ForAllSecure	Failed POV	POV		Watch
33	Disekt	Shellphish	Failed POV	POV		Watch
33	Disekt	TECHx	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
33	ForAllSecure	CodeJitsu	Failed POV	POV		Watch
33	ForAllSecure	CSDS	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
33	ForAllSecure	DeepRed	Failed POV	POV		Watch
33	ForAllSecure	Disekt	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
33	ForAllSecure	Shellphish	Failed POV	POV		Watch
33	ForAllSecure	TECHx	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
34	CSDS	CodeJitsu	Failed POV	POV		Watch
34	CSDS	DeepRed	Failed POV	POV		Watch
34	CSDS	Disekt	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
34	CSDS	ForAllSecure	Failed POV	POV		Watch
34	CSDS	Shellphish	Failed POV	POV		Watch
34	CSDS	TECHx	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
34	DeepRed	CodeJitsu	Failed POV	POV		Watch
34	DeepRed	CSDS	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
34	DeepRed	Disekt	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
34	DeepRed	ForAllSecure	Failed POV	POV		Watch
34	DeepRed	Shellphish	Failed POV	POV		Watch
34	DeepRed	TECHx	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
34	Disekt	CodeJitsu	Failed POV	POV		Watch
34	Disekt	CSDS	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
34	Disekt	DeepRed	Failed POV	POV		Watch
34	Disekt	ForAllSecure	Failed POV	POV		Watch
34	Disekt	Shellphish	Failed POV	POV		Watch
34	Disekt	TECHx	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
34	ForAllSecure	CodeJitsu	Failed POV	POV		Watch
34	ForAllSecure	CSDS	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
34	ForAllSecure	DeepRed	Failed POV	POV		Watch
34	ForAllSecure	Disekt	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch
34	ForAllSecure	Shellphish	Failed POV	POV		Watch
34	ForAllSecure	TECHx	Failed POV through defenses	POV		Watch